Vacuum Tube Manufacturing
A very small advertisement in the November, 1934, issue of QST magazine announced that a new tube, "unsurpassed in every important feature" was available from an obscure company in California. The company was Eitel-McCullough, Inc., and the tube was the 150T.
How did it all start?
In 1932 two radio amateurs, Jack McCullough (W6CHE) and Bill Eitel (W6UF), decided to build high power transmitters to work some of the 20 meter overseas stations being heard in California. They found to their dismay that the expensive transmitting tube they purchased refused to work at 1,000 volts and that was all the high voltage their power supply would provide for them.
Both were employed by the San Francisco, California, manufacturing firm of Heintz & Kaufmann, Bill Eitel and Jack McCullough convinced company president Ralph Heintz to allow them to develop a transmitting tube that could operate at lower voltages than those then available to the amateur radio market, such as the RCA 204A or the 852. Their efforts resulted in the design and production of the HK-354 tube.
They decided they could build a better tube themselves that would work at low voltage. They borrowed a modest sum and in 1934 started a company with only three people. The product was the 150T triode. From this humble beginning, the company expanded steadily. Other tubes were added to the line and the number of personnel increased slowly.
In late 1935 some tubes were sold to the U.S. Naval Research Laboratory for use in an experimental radar set that worked on 200 MHz. The 50T was the only tube that provided sufficient pulse power and that was able to stand up to the high plate voltage. More tubes were ordered by the military and in 1939 the first Navy sea radar tests used EIMAC tubes.
During 1938, the U.S. airways were developing radio beacons and high frequency radio links all over the United States. A new EIMAC tube type (450TH) was chosen for this service, and a number of other types were used for broadcast radio, including the newly-developed Armstrong FM broadcast service, and experimental television service. Radio amateurs worldwide also used EIMAC tubes as their popularity grew and dependability became known. Eitel and Armstrong were close and regularly met to discuss problems and fixes. Here is an extract of one such collaboration. Eitel & Armstrong #817.pdf
In 1940 the company received its first big war order from Western Electric for the delivery of 10,000 tubes! Up to now, an order for fifty tubes would be a cause for celebration. Converting the plant from using hand methods to mass production kept everyone working night and day for months, sent the hiring rate skyrocketing and tossed out all standard construction methods and routines. By July, 1941, the original staff was some ten times as large as it was a year earlier and the plant was doubled in size to accommodate the growing work. Expansion of the company was so fast that a second plant was opened in Salt Lake City, Utah. By 1945, EIMAC had grown to employing over 1800 people and nearly 3,500 vacuum tubes per day of all types were being manufactured.
See photo of Ginny Coutts performing tests on tubes at Eimac San Bruno. Undated but estimate 1944.
With the end of hostilities in 1945 and the subsequent cancellation of government contracts brought about a crisis at Eitel McCullough, Inc. Tube production levels fell to near-zero as government stocks of surplus tubes were dumped on the market for as little as fifteen cents each. The Salt Lake City plant was sadly closed.
Foreseeing the end of the war, however, EIMAC engineers had evolved new tube types, including production of the new beam tetrode (4X150A) which performed well in the VHF region. At the same time, a new Salt Lake City plant was opened to make television picture tubes (CRT's). The future of the company now no longer depended upon the older tubes that were so plentiful on the surplus market. One feature of the Salt Lake City plant was that it manufactured every component of the tube under the one roof.
In 1958 a new Eitel-McCullough plant was built in San Carlos, California, for production of new tetrode tubes, plus larger tubes for broadcast and TV service. At the same time, TV klystrons and other microwave devices were developed for troposcatter communications.
In 1965 Eitel-McCullough merged with Varian Associates of Palo Alto, California. The Varian Eimac divisions continued manufacturing all types of transmitting tubes and are well known worldwide while the Klystron products were transferred from San Carlos to Palo Alto to be made under the Varian logo.
Varian Eimac developed super-power tubes for broadcast service using pyrolytic graphite grids made using a novel laser-milling operation to achieve increased tube performance, stability and higher power output. Modern Eimac manufacturing techniques have led to improved VHF performance in large power grid tubes such as the 4CM2500KG, a tetrode that is being evaluated for the Department of Energy’s fusion research program.
The UHF Klystrode® combines the features of the klystron and the tetrode and was developed at Eimac by Donald Preist, Sr. scientist and Merrald B. Shrader, an ex-RCA tube design engineer, as program manager. The Klystrode® was later renamed the Inductive Output Tube (IOT) for better market recognition. The original IOT was conceived by A.V. Haeff at RCA in 1938 but it was never made in a high power commercial version; the concept was successfully proven by Eimac and IOTs supplied for high power amplification for UHF television systems as well as scientific accelerators and other applications where high operating efficiency and its small size makes an IOT preferable to a Klystron.
In 1989, as a result of the energy efficient Klystrode® IOT, Varian’s Eimac division was awarded an Engineering Emmy® for technological achievement by the Academy of Television Arts and Sciences. The first Eimac Klystrode IOT’s used in broadcasting were installed at WCES-TV in Augusta, GA in 1988.
In 1984, Bill Eitel and Jack McCullough both retired and maintained a strong interest in the company and, of course, in their amateur radio activities. The EIMAC divisions of Varian owe a great deal to amateur radio for it was in this field that many of the early transmitting tubes proved their worth and -even today- many of the company's customers are radio amateurs.
As Bill and Jack said, "If it were not for amateur radio, EIMAC could never have existed."
Eimac even owned a commercial broadcast station! KSBR was licensed to Eitel McCullough in 1947. The factory engineers built the transmitter which was located at Mt. Diablo and with a TPO of 50 kW and ERP of 300 kW, it had an exceedingly broad coverage area and was used for testing tubes in “real-world” performance. It was said poor reliability of the antenna was a major problem due to rf heating and corona and ultimately the station ceased operating; KSBR is now assigned to a college station in Southern California.
The 301 Industrial Rd. plant in San Carlos was built specifically as a dedicated tube manufacturing facility, not some building that was adapted or re-purposed into that kind of function. It consisted of a 330K square-foot building with multiple city-gas powered generators for back-up power capability.
Eimac’s marketing staff often found other products to add to the tube factory and in several cases Eimac spawned technologies that ultimately led to other companies capitalizing on the work. In the 60’s as ceramic-metal seals were perfected for tubes, Eimac offered a broad line of ceramic feedthroughs. These were used in vacuum chambers by science laboratories and some special purpose ceramics were built for detonator squibs. When a budding new medical firm needed small hermetic ruby feedthroughs for cardiac Pacemakers, Eimac ultimately delivered in excess of 50K parts for that application.
A ceramic-bodied high intensity lamp named the Illuminator was developed by Eimac. The brightest lamps available, illuminators were employed in military vehicles and helicopters as spot lights and in medical endoscopy. The Illuminator patents# and assets were sold to ILC Technology, subsequently owned by Lumen Technologies and later acquired by Perkin Elmer in 1998.
Then there was the semiconductor company that operated within Eimac’s San Carlos facility. Communications Transistor Corporation, known as CTC, was a Varian-funded startup around 1969, when some Fairchild Semiconductor employees were hired and later operated at the Eimac plant from 1975 until 1981 when Varian sold the business to Acrian. During that period CTC led in state-of-the-art RF semiconductors and competed with Motorola Semiconductor. In 1991, the CTC; now Acrian assets and technology were acquired by Ericsson and GHZ Technology. Ironically, Varian was directly involved with the semiconductor industry, the very thing that would eventually displace power grid tubes for RF amplifiers. Today many vacuum tube transmitters continue to operate, but since the 1990’s solid state technology has become the norm for new high power RF amplifiers$.
Little has ever been published about the Nuclear Battery that Eimac developed for the Sandia Laboratories National Laboratory. Built at the San Carlos plant around 1961, it was intended for orbiting space applications. Apparently the nuclear lab was setup in a closed room and no hazard signs posted, it was somewhat of a cold war secret project that never eventuated. The nuclear battery / cell used Krypton 85 and it was introduced into a vial and a reaction occurred that generated an electrical current.
Gordon Lavering noted the device had to survive several environmental tests, one of which was thermal storage at low temperatures. Stan Jepson's group brought down a bunch of "Nucs" to be left in the Environmental Test Lab's cold chamber over one weekend, and Dan Danilian was assigned the task to come in Sunday and remove the samples from the cold chamber. When Dan opened the cold chamber he found that one of the Nucs had cracked and, therefore, the internal gas escaped out the Building 1 door and floated somewhere down the Bayshore Freeway!
In 1995, Leonard Green & Partners purchased the Electron Device Business which included the Eimac divisions from Varian and formed Communications & Power Industries, Inc. now operating under parent company CPI International (CPII).
In 1997 the ceramic tube portion of Eimac’s Salt Lake City operation was moved to San Carlos while the glass tube products were discontinued and that production equipment was sold to Triton Services of Easton, PA. Previously Triton was known as the ITT Electron Tube business since 1964 and in 2008 Triton closed its doors.
70th Anniversary - 2005
In 2007 the last remaining Eimac plant at San Carlos was closed and consolidated into CPI’s Microwave Power Tube operation in Palo Alto. The 18.1 acre property at 301 Industrial Rd. was sold to the Palo Alto Medical Foundation and in 2014 PAMF completed a modern $230M hospital* at the same 301 Industrial Rd. address Eimac used for 48 years.
A history compilation is available here, see [/www.cpii.com/history.cfm http://www.cpii.com/history.cfm]; noting the name Eimac& is retained as a Trademark of CPII.
In January 2004, affiliates of The Cypress Group, a private equity fund, acquired CPI.
In February 2011, an affiliate of Veritas Capital Fund Management LLC, a private equity investment firm, acquired CPI from The Cypress Group.
CPI again changed hands in late 2017 !
# Varian Illuminator patent US 4179037 link: [/www.google.com/patents/US4179037 https://www.google.com/patents/US4179037]
$ [/en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nautel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nautel]
& [/wikivisually.com/wiki/Eimac http://wikivisually.com/wiki/Eimac]
Many of the people working at Eimac were amateur radio operators, and indeed made significant contributions outside their Eimac interests:
- George M.W. Badger (1925 - 2009), W6TC, ex W6RXW was another standout engineer. Born February 22, 1925, he grew up in Berkeley, California where he attended University High School before being drafted into the Army in 1943. After the war George attended UC Berkeley where he graduated BSEE 1951 and was one of the earlier graduate engineers to be hired by Eitel McCullough where he worked on all manner of projects, like running the laboratory facility that attempted to adapt the Lawrence color-TV picture tube for production (Eimac was making Black and White picture tubes for RCA Victor at their Salt Lake City plant at the time). He headed up an important competitive “save” from RCA in the late ‘50s. George was marketing manager at San Carlos and responsible for selling the first Klystrode IOT tubes to broadcast OEM’s. After George’s retirement, he ran the marketing operation for Svetlana America, and when that folded, he moved to Econco, now a subsidiary of CPI.
- Don Preist was employed with Eimac from 1946-1992 and retired as Senior Scientist. Don was responsible for the successful introduction of the Klystrode/IOT for television broadcast and was involved with the development of a 250 kW (CW) 267MHz IOT built for Chalk River National Labs (Canada) where it performed at better than 70% efficiency.
- W.I. “Bill” Orr, W6SAI, Chief Applications Engineer, was a prolific technical writer for Eimac and is credited with much work on the 3-500Z and 3-1000Z tubes... one of his set of tube notes is shown in the document archive (below). Bill Orr and Bill Eitel both contributed to project OSCAR, the first privately owned satellite launched in 1962. Bill was responsible for publishing and advertising until that position was eliminated in 1984.
- Jack Kendall, KC5GBF, was responsible for putting into production the 3CX2500 series triodes, later to become the 3CX3000 tubes when ceramic was used, and planar triodes and was employed first in San Carlos and later at the Salt Lake City plant where he retired as development engineer around 1984.
- W.H. “Bill” Sain, mathematician and tube designer who was responsible for all of San Carlos Eimac new tube designs until his death in 1985. Bill designed the 8877 from start to finish in 10 months.
- Robert I. "Bob" Sutherland, (1926-2004) W6PO (ex-W6UOV) was on the West Coast end of the first Amateur Radio moonbounce (EME) contact in 1960 when the Eimac Radio Club's W6HB and W1BU worked each other on 1296 MHz EME. An employee of Eimac for nearly 50 years, Sutherland, who directed the Advanced Products Lab, developed some of the more famous Eimac tube-based amps. His Eimac 8877 VHF amplifier design still is referred to as "the W6PO amp."
- Jack Quinn, W6MZ, marketing manager following O.H. “Hank” Brown, W6HB. Jack came to Eimac San Carlos with experience in shortwave broadcast as engineer at VOA’s Delano station and GE’s high power shortwave station KGEI. Varian’s moving the Klystron production from San Carlos to Palo Alto left a void which led to Eimac engineers focusing on new large “Megawatt” power grid tubes for shortwave and medium-wave broadcasting and that ultimately led to the development of high power tubes for scientific applications.
- Reid Brandon, W6MTF, applications engineer at Eimac San Carlos from 1983-2013, technical writer of publications including the Care and Feeding of Power Grid Tubes and product data sheets and responsible for product failure analysis.
- Joseph (Buzz) Miklos, WA4GPM , engineering manager R&D at Eimac Salt Lake City.
- Werner Brunhart. Werner came to Eimac Salt Lake City from Machlett Laboratories. Werner was the engineer and marketing manager, with a background in planar triodes he was a key member in the development of microwave triodes and high voltage switch tubes used in particle accelerators (SLAC).
- Willis B. Foote, K6BCM, Chief Specifications Engineer, San Carlos responsible for printing tube data sheets.
- Robert Mc Donald, W6JYT now K7RSM, engineer at CTC and co-founder of Acrian.
- Smith G. Washburn (1914-1996). Smith's estate was the source of most of the photographs used here.
- Gordon Lavering, ex-Eimac engineer.
- Warren Struven.
Archives & Manufacturing data
The Tube Collectors Association is the current caretaker of the Perham-Eimac Archive. The Perham-Eimac Archive consists of 48 shelf-feet of Eimac tube manufacturing information from 1942 to 1960 plus several cabinets of legal and miscellaneous information. this archive is available by arrangement to anyone wanting to do tube research. Please contact Ludwell Sibley, Oregon, if interested in using these archives. ** interesting follow up...
Acknowledgements and request for comments, photos, memorabilia etc.
Much of the information collected here is a result of gracious and sharing individuals. If you can assist in expanding any information, please ask the IEEE History Committee or e-mail David Burger at email@example.com ) *** If you possess or have access to any photos of the San Carlos plant, please make contact to see if we can obtain permission to get that part of the Eimac story communicated here.. please...
A special thanks for contributions and resources (some too big for me to deal with from Australia) to the following people:
- Mr Dave L. Washburn of Fresno, CA
- Mrs Kathleen Sliter, Dayton, NV
- Mr Ludwell Sibley. Tube Collectors
- Mr Reid Brandon, San Mateo, CA
- Ms Linda Di Lorenzo, CPI
- The ARRL Publications Committee.
Please refer to the individual photo metadata for contributor acknowledgements and related information.