Thread history

Time User Activity Comment
11:30, 8 March 2014 Djkemp (talk | contribs) New reply created (Reply to Committee Comments)
22:07, 7 March 2014 Jbart64 (talk | contribs) New reply created (Reply to Committee Comments)
22:25, 3 March 2014 Sherwoodluo (talk | contribs) New reply created (Reply to Committee Comments)
00:09, 28 February 2014 Lisetiffner (talk | contribs) New reply created (Reply to Committee Comments)
16:01, 18 February 2014 Tbickart (talk | contribs) New reply created (Reply to Committee Comments)
20:59, 16 February 2014 Feisel (talk | contribs) New thread created  

I don't know much about the history of breaking Enigma but this appears to be well documented and should be a worthy milestone. A comment: There is no indication of WHERE this activity took place. The first sentence of the citation seems a bit terse. Could it start with, "Near this site..." or "At such-and-such location..."? I think it would be more meaningful to the reader.

Feisel20:59, 16 February 2014

I agree with Lyle and believe that this achievement is worthy of being an IEEE Milestone.

Tbickart16:01, 18 February 2014
 

It helped speed the end of WWII. Not sure that it ended WWII with American assistance.

Lise Johnston00:09, 28 February 2014
 

I agree in general that this is worthy recognition as an IEEE milestone. What could be emphasized more is how this event is related to IEEE and it's predecessors.

Sherwoodluo22:25, 3 March 2014
 

I agree with Feisel's comments that the wording is a bit terse, or even awkward, and there is no location. The documentation is reasonable and the sources are the basic ones that I am familiar with regarding the history of codes and the enigma. The basic claim is valid. However, the last sentence is a bit vague...was the American support to win the war (true), or was it to work on enigma coding issues (not so true)? I support the concept of this milestone, but it is not ready for a final vote. Additional editing is needed. --Dave Bart

Jbart6422:07, 7 March 2014
 

I support the milestone. This was a significant breakthrough leading to the end of the war.

Djkemp11:30, 8 March 2014